My Client Wanted to List Higher Than I Recommended. Here's What Happened Next.
Sandra Alonso explaining home pricing strategy to seller
Let me tell you a story I've lived more than once — and one that every seller in South Miami-Dade needs to hear before they sign a listing agreement.
I sat across from a seller — a lovely person, someone who had taken real pride in their home, put money into it, cared for it for years. We went through the comparable sales together. I showed them what similar homes in the neighborhood had sold for in the past 90 days. I gave them my honest recommendation on price.
And then they said: "I want to list it higher."
I understood. I really did. That home meant something to them. Every upgrade, every memory, every Saturday morning spent in that backyard — it all had value. Just not the kind of value that shows up on a CMA.
So we listed it at their number. And here's what happened.
The First Two Weeks: Silence
The listing went live. It looked beautiful — great photos, strong description, well-marketed. And then... we waited.
Serious buyers in this market are informed. They've been watching Zillow, Realtor.com, and the MLS for weeks, sometimes months. They know what things are worth in Palmetto Bay and Cutler Bay. When a home is priced above market, they don't call to negotiate — they just move on. They assume the seller isn't serious, or they don't want to insult anyone, so they simply don't show up.
Showings were sparse. The feedback we did get was polite but consistent: "Love the home, concerned about the price."
The Danger Zone: Days on Market
Here's what most sellers don't realize: the longer a home sits on the market, the more power shifts to the buyer.
After 30 days, buyers start asking questions. "Why is it still available? Is something wrong with it? Is the seller desperate?" Even if the home is perfect, the stigma of sitting too long is real. Buyers who might have offered close to asking price in week one will come in with lowball offers in week five — because now they feel they have leverage.
The original price didn't protect the seller. It cost them.
The Price Reduction: Too Little, Too Late?
Eventually, we reduced the price — to right around where I had originally recommended. And do you know what happened? The phone started ringing again.
But here's the painful part: the buyers who came in after a price reduction are not the same buyers who would have come in on day one. The motivated, qualified buyers who were watching from the beginning had already moved on and bought something else. The ones left in the pool? They're the ones looking for a deal. They know the history. They see the DOM — days on market — and they negotiate harder.
We did sell the home. But the seller netted less than they would have if we had priced it right from the start — and the process took three times as long, with three times the stress.
What I Wish Every Seller Knew
Pricing your home correctly from day one is not about leaving money on the table. It's about maximizing what you actually walk away with.
A well-priced home in a good market creates competition. When multiple buyers are interested at the same time, you get multiple offers. Multiple offers give you leverage. Leverage gets you closer to — or sometimes above — your asking price, faster, with fewer headaches.
An overpriced home does the opposite. It sits. It stagnates. It trains buyers to wait you out.
My job is not to tell you what you want to hear. My job is to tell you what will actually get you the most money. Sometimes those are the same thing. Sometimes they're not. And when they're not, I'm going to be honest with you — because that's what you're hiring me for.
Thinking About Selling or Buying?
Before you pick a number, let's talk. I'll give you a thorough market analysis, an honest price recommendation, and a marketing plan that puts your home in front of the right buyers from day one.
No pressure. Just real data and straight talk. Request your free home valuation here.
→ What is your home really worth?
— Sandra K. Alonso, PA
REALTOR® | Brown Harris Stevens
Palmetto Bay & Cutler Bay Specialist














